Sax on the Web Forum banner

Reed geek alternative

1.5K views 29 replies 22 participants last post by  turf3  
#1 ·
I think the Reed Geek is cool, but it's too expensive. Is there an alternative available in Europe? Thanks.
 
#3 ·
Lathe bits are a couple of Euros.
 
#4 ·
#13 ·
Nothing really if it works for you and you're comfortable with that method. I went through periods of using just sandpaper and also just using a reed knife for everything. Now I use a reed knife or ReedGeek like tool (lathe bit, etc.) to deal with the swelling and flatten the backs of reeds. I use sandpaper on the front if I feel I need to soften them up a bit. For me this combination is what works best and makes it easiest for me to get the results I want.
 
#18 ·
+1 for a lathe bit. After that you shouldn't get the cheapest
For optimum straightness of the edge, a lathe bit may need finishing on a sharpening stone (which, in turn, would ever so often need flattening by the flattening stone).

Medium-priced lathe bits have edges that need minimal finishing effort. You will be still ahead compared to buying the Geek.
 
#21 ·
A folding tanto knife works well too.

 
#23 ·
For a reed that’s warped, the best thing I’ve found is the triangular scraper. Music Medic sells one, but you can get these at well-stocked tool stores too. Triangle Scraper

The reed geek / lathe bit tools do well at removing the uneven fibers on the back of the reed, I use one on every reed I play. But for a badly warped reed, the triangle scraper is best. Of course for a badly warped reed, the chances are it’s toast no matter what you do….

Reed rush AKA Dutch rush AKA scouring rush (Latin name “equisetum hyemale”) grows wild everywhere in the world, often next to small streams and creeks. Many nurserys sell it by the pot (5-gallon pot at a nursery near me is less than $20). Often used as decorative ground cover. Be careful - it spreads easily and is hard to get rid of.

I used to use reed rush all the time, but actually prefer sandpaper. I use either 320 or 400 grit wet or dry, cut into small pieces.