Sax on the Web Forum banner

Your opinion of my tone :)

3.1K views 15 replies 10 participants last post by  Maddcow  
#1 ·
Hey guys,

I've been having a lot of trouble with my sound lately and I was wondering if I could get some feedback from you guys. It would be greatly appreciated. The audio clip I posted is just some random improv of me playing over a mixolydian b6 mode that I was messing around with, nothing virtuosic. I'm looking for comments on:

- what elements of my sound need work?
- what elements of my sound you like?
- originality of my sound...or do I sound like a clone?
- possible ways/exercises of improving my tone?

And please I'm not interested in talking about the gear I use...to me that is all secondary.

I'm aiming one day to achieve a nasally sound much like that of Kenny Garrett so if any of you have any advice on how to do that it would be greatly appreciated.

And a little background info on myself. I just started my first year of uni doing a Bmus in Melbourne, Australia where I'm majoring in jazz/improv performance. I've been playing 'jazz' for around 2 years but originally I was classically trained on the clarinet and saxophone from the age of 11. My main axe is the alto (which I'm playing in the audio clip) but I also play a lot of sop.

Thanks for taking the time to listen/read/give feedback. I really appreciate it as it'll go a long way in helping me improve my playing. Hope you all enjoy :)

 
#2 ·
Sounds good to me.

So you want to get a little more edge and brightness a la Kenny Garrett? Are you in the process of learning any Kenny Garrett Solos? That would be the place to start if you want a sound closer to his. Learn to play along. Match his inflections.

You aren't far off now. You just have to push the horn a little more to get that sound. I'm sure in Uni you'll have projects to lift solos from records. I hope at least...
 
#3 ·
We do a lot of transcribing at uni and I have done a lot of Kenny Garrett transcriptions in the past. Although I've focused mainly on getting the notes and copying his time rather than copying his phrasing/time/articulation etc. which in my head is more important but defiantly more difficult.
 
#5 ·
Hey, thanks for responding warp x. I was playing slowly on purpose because I'm more interested in people analysing my quality of sound than anything else. I was actually almost going to record myself just playing long tones initially. I don't think just because someone is play fairly diatonic and slowly means you can't critique their sound...in fact I think it makes it easier. Also the majority of my notes were centered around the middle D on alto. And I ventured pretty evenly across the range in my own opinion. Thanks for your opinion anyway. Hopefully if I have time tomorrow I'll record myself playing over a tune and upload it.

Cheers.
 
#6 ·
I can imagine KG sounding something like this if he were playing what you played. But the true test would be playing as aggressivly as KG does and playing the "quarter tones" (not sure that is exactly what they would be called) - those intemediate/indeterminate tones he integrates into his sound. I do think you are in the ballpark of KG's sound.
 
#7 ·
First of all love the sound you are producing. You are going in the right direction. Secondly, get a couple of your favorite Kenny Garrett tunes loaded on your ipod or your digital playback device, and attempt to match his playing. You'll find that repetition of this exercise will get you really close to the sound that you desire. Here is a Youtube link to Kenny Garrett videos which you should find helpful.
.
Keep up the great work.
 
#8 ·
Sounds to me as though you're "holding back" and trying to produce a mellow tone. Nothing wrong with that, but try experimenting with using more breath support and putting more air through the horn, even when sub-toning.
 
#9 ·
Has a Cannonball Adderley quality to it.
 
#16 ·
Agreed.