JamGo: I see lot's of "looks" but no replies. So here's one, from a guy who doesn't play tenor. My comments are about saxophones in general, though - the presence or absence of a hi-F# key is meaningless in the big scheme of things. I have sopranos and altos with and without that feature and I don't think it matters. Others may disagree.
As far as the finish goes, lot's of disagreement about that, too. But in the end, I've never seen a convincing argument for having an un-lacquered saxophone except for the esthetic qualities of the "aged" look. If those two finishes were up to me, I'd go with the silver-plate if for no other reason than the horn's finish will be protected for years longer than having no lacquer. I have a 1925 Buescher alto and a 1928 Buescher soprano in silver that are STILL stunning. DAVE
I bought a Z Unlackered Z
Also onwed a Z lackered tenor a few years back!
As for sound,in my opinion,no difference!
I prefer the alto way better then the tenor,and again only my opinion,which some wont agree!
As far as the finish,it does nt matter to me,shiny or a old lookin saxe after about a year and a half,but be prepared that it ages very fast,and darl spot here which are not the nices thing on a horn!
If you take it with a finish,then much easier to keep it in beautifull looking look,If you want that!
Best of luck in your choice!
My best regards
I have the silver plated 82z tenor w/high F#. All I can say is that for me this is a wonderful instrument and that I couldn't be happier with it. It is a very, very strong player. Placing a couple of 3M anti tarnish strips in the instruments case will help maintain the silver shiny.
I have an unlacquered Z, both for tenor and alto.
I tried al of the finishes and liked these most. Silver plated would have been my 2nd choice. I really felt a lot of difference in the different finishes.
To me it seemed that the silverplated is a little darker than the other finishes and the unlacquered both has the the dark and strong low end of the silver plated, but also has a lot of harmonics and brilliance to the sound in the higher register.
I agree with Wietse in that by direct A-B comparison my silver Z seemed to have more core sound than the other Zs i tried, but i never attributed that difference to the finish, yet I am open to the possibility.
A forum community dedicated to saxophone players and enthusiasts bought to you by Harri Rautiainen. Come join the discussion about collections, care, displays, models, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!