I don't think there's really any substitute for a real teacher (i.e., someone who will watch and/or listen to you play and give you feedback), especially when you're first starting out.
Lots of teachers offer remote lessons (in a variety of formats) these days, and I think it would be worth doing something like that for at least a few months as you ease back into playing.
In terms of lesson plans and subscriptions, I think a really good option that you didn't list is Steve Neff's (user @Nefertiti on SOTW) offerings. I was a member many years ago, back around the time when Steve first put it together, and I found that there were a great variety of solid lesson topics and materials back then, targeting players across the full range of playing ability. You'd now have the advantage of more than a decade of additions.
One of the problems with a la carte subscriptions though is that (like watching a bunch of YouTube videos), it can lead you to try to do too much at once, leaving you feeling overwhelmed and frustrated. Conversely, structured lesson plans made for mass consumption can wind up moving way too slowly. Part of what real teachers do is to act like coaches: guiding your progress based on your strengths and weaknesses and based on your rate of improvement, and tailoring their suggested practice routines accordingly. There's no real substitute for that.
Lots of teachers offer remote lessons (in a variety of formats) these days, and I think it would be worth doing something like that for at least a few months as you ease back into playing.
In terms of lesson plans and subscriptions, I think a really good option that you didn't list is Steve Neff's (user @Nefertiti on SOTW) offerings. I was a member many years ago, back around the time when Steve first put it together, and I found that there were a great variety of solid lesson topics and materials back then, targeting players across the full range of playing ability. You'd now have the advantage of more than a decade of additions.
One of the problems with a la carte subscriptions though is that (like watching a bunch of YouTube videos), it can lead you to try to do too much at once, leaving you feeling overwhelmed and frustrated. Conversely, structured lesson plans made for mass consumption can wind up moving way too slowly. Part of what real teachers do is to act like coaches: guiding your progress based on your strengths and weaknesses and based on your rate of improvement, and tailoring their suggested practice routines accordingly. There's no real substitute for that.
