Shmazzy said:
I am aware that ultimatley the only way I'll be able to decide is to try them out myself but I just need this as a starting point.
Good point. Pretty sure that if everybody lists his tip, you have to try out the complete stock of three big music stores though
Serious, I second master.america : try everything possible. Don't try mpc that are very cheap though, specially with the metal ones. You're bound to be dissatisfied I found out myself.
BergLarsen is my main choice (I have two of them). I also have a Selmer Goldentone, and it's very good but not my style.
Meyer are (very) good mouthpieces. tried them on soprano, and loved them. Don't know for tenor,but heard good comments. BergLarsen hard rubber are great mouthpieces (tried one, but I stick with my metal one for the bright edge).
Something to consider : I particularly like BergLarsen hard rubber and metal pieces because they have a "smaller" feel : I don't have such a big mouth (my mom would disagree though). The slim form of these mouthpieces feel more natural for me and thus makes them easier to play. Plus they're great tonewise, but I play mainly ska. I love subtoning too, but I like a "roar" in my sax.
edit : BergLarsen stainless steel are controversial pieces. You either love them or you hate them. They have a very specific sound.