Sax on the Web Forum banner
1 - 16 of 16 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
So I currently play alto sax in my school band and ive been playing for about a year, I'm 14, and the only reason I started playing saxophone is because of the barry sax. Ive been really wanting to play it but I feel like I'm not good enough, I feel like I should wait a year or 2 and then see where I am. Any tips
 

· Distinguished SOTW Member
Joined
·
9,423 Posts
Quick story; 12 yrs old, playing clarinet for a year, probably the worst player in the band. When I learned the school was buying a baritone sax, I begged to play it. I guess they figured they had nothing to lose so they did. It wasn't long before I was the section leader of the saxes and going to all-state band. I have played sax ever since, 62 years, mostly a tenor player but since 1998 I have had a baritone - I got the alto in 1983 and the soprano in 1998 too.

'not good enough'; you'll find the baritone parts in school band swing between playing bass parts with the low brass and being a part of the sax section. It doesn't take much skill to play the 'oom-pahs' with the sousaphones and a sax part is a sax part. It might take a little more air and of course the horn gets heavy in a parade, but if you are of average size you should be able to do it.

School baritones usually get beat up. When you try it, there could be many reasons that you might have trouble with it, from leaks, damage or even a damaged mouthpiece. If this is the case, you'll have to get them to authorize repairs so you'll have a legitimate shot at making it work.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
586 Posts
Personally, I think the bari sax is easier to play than the alto, so I don't see any reason to wait, as long as you can carry it without strain. The bari needs quite a lot of air.

Potential problems with the bari:
1. Weight - you may want a harness to carry it comfortably, but I wouldn't think that weight would be a big problem for a 14-year-old. (An 8-year-old might find the bari a bit heavy!)
2. Cost - the sax, the mouthpiece and the reeds all cost a lot more than alto.

But the bari is great fun to play.
 

· Distinguished SOTW Member, Forum Contributor 2015-
Joined
·
38,823 Posts
Personally, I think the bari sax is easier to play than the alto, so I don't see any reason to wait, as long as you can carry it without strain. The bari needs quite a lot of air.

Potential problems with the bari:
1. Weight - you may want a harness to carry it comfortably, but I wouldn't think that weight would be a big problem for a 14-year-old. (An 8-year-old might find the bari a bit heavy!)
News flash: Strength and size does not scale with age. My horn tech in NM would not work on bari saxes because they were too large for her to comfortably handle. I stopped playing bari after age 50 or so because of the weight, and I'm 6'4".

My son, at 13 and 6'2", would be happy with one, yet most of his peers may never find them manageable.

Bottom line: OP, we cannot tell whether you can play a bari - size, strength, asthma?. Please try one, then get back to us.
 

· Distinguished SOTW Member, Forum Contributor 2016
Joined
·
20,655 Posts
News flash: Strength and size does not scale with age.
But doesn't it to a degree ?

I also know a tech down here who refuses to do Bari work any longer. He is 70 years old and while in good health, he just doesn't like maneuvering around them on the bench any longer, picking 'em up, putting 'em down, testing 'em....

And certainly, a 15 year old is gonna be able to handle a bighorn better than a 10-year old, even if the former is on the small side, I'd say. I would not be inclined to suggest a baritone to a pre-teen, myself...

So I currently play alto sax in my school band and ive been playing for about a year, I'm 14, and the only reason I started playing saxophone is because of the barry sax. Ive been really wanting to play it but I feel like I'm not good enough, I feel like I should wait a year or 2 and then see where I am. Any tips
You can go either way. I agree with above statement, approach your band director and see if they are warm to the idea of you moving to the Bighorn. If so...do it (providing your family can afford one or the school has a loaner/rental which, as Saxman states, is in DECENT playing shape).

If the director (and your teacher for that matter, if you take private lessons) feels you are not ready, then stay with Alto another year - and let it be known to them your goal is to get to the Bighorn, just so they understand your desire.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
4,358 Posts
As a saxophone teacher and music educator my advice has always been to stay on your initial instrument until you have mastered the fundamentals of tone production and technique throughout the range of the instrument before switching to a double, or a different size woodwind in the same family. I know there are circumstances that make this impractical such as the band director saying "the jazz ensemble needs a tenor sax" etc., but in the long run there is the risk of becoming a "jack of all instruments and master of none" which in my teaching experience is all too common.
 

· Registered
Conn NW II Soprano, NW I Alto, 10M Tenor, NW I C Melody & Allora Bari.
Joined
·
349 Posts
Did you ever talk to your band director about your desire to play the Baritone Saxophone one day? Even if you do wait, he / she may let you try it before the big switch.
 

· Distinguished SOTW Member, Forum Contributor 2008,
Joined
·
3,878 Posts
Go ahead, play bari! If I hadn't picked up bari as a sophomore in high school, I probably would've quit band before I graduated. Would've greatly changed my life!
 

· Registered
YTS-82Z; B991; 'Crat 1 alto
Joined
·
1,689 Posts
My very short daughter, now 24, switched from alto to bari in middle school. She played bari in both regular band and jazz ensemble.

Do it! There are always too many altos anyway.

Hear the bottom. Be the bottom.
 
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top