Sax on the Web Forum banner
1 - 11 of 11 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,393 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Do you like silver plated saxes? If so why? It seems to me that owning a silver plated sax just means you spend all your time with a polishing cloth, but I fully realise that I am a lazy slob with a don't care attitude, so educate me... what's good about a silver plated sax?

OK, so my next question is, if you're going to silver plate a sax why not apply a clear lacquer coat over the top so that you can have your nice, shiny, silver finish and not have to keep polishing it? Or am I missing the point here?

If you don't like silver, what plate or lacquer finish would you specify? What about gold plate? Nickel silver? What about a special "vintage" finish or a brushed finish or actually do you just prefer plain old fashioned gold lacquer and be done with it?

All opinions are gratefully received...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
762 Posts
Hey Rick,

Some people feel the sound is richer on a silver plated horn. With regards to the clear coat, you may find this link useful:

http://www.saxontheweb.net/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=40878

I'm in discussions with a company here in the UK (FH Lambert. Do a google search) to have the bell and crook on my tenor silver plated, but if money was no object, I'd like to have the whole horn gold plated. Saw a series II tenor recently. W_O_W !!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
778 Posts
Hi Rick. Several arguments on this board about the effects of lacquer verses silver plating on a sax. Some feel it makes no difference to the sound on a particular model of sax and some do. I believe silver plating makes a difference on the sound. Lacquer slightly deadens the high harmonics one hears over a lacquered sax. Thus the sound in my view is slightly richer and more robust; just my experience each time I've tested lacquered models vs. their silver plated models. I've had several silver plated saxes, a Series III and a Z in both tenor and alto versions. Over the lacquered versions, the silver plated horns had a bigger richer sound. Not sure how I feel about silver plated horns in a classical setting, however, for jazz, their wonderful. Are they a hastle to clean? Yes. But wipping them down after each play and keeping silver strips in the case helps a lot.

On the subject of lacquer over silver plating, the silver will still tarnish, especially when exposed to the sun of any length of time, like in an outdoor concert. Unfortunately, there is nothing you can do to polish it if there is a lacquered coat.

Just my experience. Naturally there will be those that disagree with the effect of silver plating vs. lacquer.
 

·
Forum Contributor 2015, SOTW Better late than neve
Joined
·
4,273 Posts
Silver plate just looks cool even if it's tarnished some. Sound wise I think there's a bit more resonance over lacquer. Not much to the listener to even think about or notice.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,393 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Thanks guys I really appreciate your thoughts. Personally I'm a fully paid up member of the "what it's made of doesn't affect the tone" school of thought, but I still think that there is aesthetic value in different finishes of sax.
Saxplayer1 said:
On the subject of lacquer over silver plating, the silver will still tarnish, especially when exposed to the sun of any length of time, like in an outdoor concert. Unfortunately, there is nothing you can do to polish it if there is a lacquered coat.
Really? I assumed it was to do with oxygen from the air coming into contact with the silver. That's certainly something to consider.
 

·
Distinguished SOTW Member and Old King Log
Joined
·
801 Posts
It has to do more with the various sulphides floating about (SO2, SO4) and the nitrous oxides (NOx) than it does with the oxygen.

A silver plated horn requires a bit more attention in Houston (where we have photochemical smog in abundance) that it ever did in rural Illinois (where I used to live).

One other oddity about the atmosphere down here. I once did a big band job on the deck of the USS Texas, the last remaining dreadnought era battleship in the world which is preserved in a park setting on our Ship Channel next to all of the petrochemical industry. Other than location, there was nothing unusual about the job, excepting only one thing:

On my YBS 62 and on another player's YTS-62, all of the posts holding up the keywork became discolored. (The color shifted from the same as the rest of the horn to something more dark and smoky like.) None of the posts on any of the other saxes changed like this (including a YAS-63 alto), and while subtle at the time, by the end of the job all were noticeably darker than the rest of the horn.

Over time most of the shift has gone away, but the posts still are a bit darker than the rest of the horn.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
762 Posts
Saxplayer1 said:
On the subject of lacquer over silver plating, the silver will still tarnish, especially when exposed to the sun of any length of time, like in an outdoor concert. Unfortunately, there is nothing you can do to polish it if there is a lacquered coat.
Only if the lacquer is damaged. Same as brass.
 

·
Distinguished SOTW Member
Joined
·
878 Posts
Silver makes for a nicer looking horn, but it does take more work, especially if you opt for the satin silver finish. Anytime I bring my Chu out to a band job, people just ooh and ah over it. Also, if you're in a situation where you are using colored stage lighting, the satin silver will take the color of the lights, really cool stuff.

Other than that, it's a pain in the butt to maintain. That's why when I purchased my Big B Aristocrat, I opted to go with lacquer over silver. It's simply easier to care for, and that is probably one of the reasons why silver horns went out of vogue in the 1930s, that and the depressed economy of the time made lacquer horns more practical.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
864 Posts
Silver-plating makes a big difference

The notion of enhances higher-harmonics is extremely correct! I currently play a silver Yamaha 875 and the high harmonics NEVER go away. Ever. (Granted, I'm playing a Freddie Gregory Mk II 7**.) I've recently tried this horn back-to-back with a black lacquer and a normal lacquer. Big differences between all three.

This can be a good thing or a bad thing, depending on the player's objectives for sound. I find it very hard to get a traditional dark jazz sound (a la Dexter Gordon, Stanley Turrrentine, etc.) out of this horn.

Just my two cents.
 

·
SOTW Columnist, Distinguished SOTW Member
Joined
·
23,679 Posts
BBJQSAX said:
I currently play a silver Yamaha 875 and the high harmonics NEVER go away.
....I find it very hard to get a traditional dark jazz sound (a la Dexter Gordon, Stanley Turrrentine, etc.) out of this horn. .
I doubt the lack of a "traditional dark jazz sound" has anything to do with the silver plate. More likely it's a combination of the horn itself, the mpc, and the player. I'm not entirely convinced that plating makes no difference in the sound, but it would be a very subtle thing if it does. There are multiple threads on whether there is a sound difference or not, so I'll leave that idea alone.

Regarding care, looks, durability, etc., silver plate is probably the most durable of all the finishes. It won't wear off nearly as fast as lacquer. I have a '39 Aristocrat tenor with original silver plate that looks brand new. I also think silver looks great, for what that's worth. And I don't find it difficult to maintain. I just wipe it down every other day or so, depending on how much I've been playing, and also put one of those silver protection strips in the case. My other silver-plated tenor ("156" 'Crat) was newly plated at Anderson's about 5 years ago and it still looks pristine. So it's not that big of a deal to maintain. But maybe if you live in an industrial area with lots of sulfur in the air it would be a different situation.
 

·
Distinguished SOTW Member and Old King Log
Joined
·
801 Posts
As I've said, I live and play in the Houston area, where our Ship Channel industrial area has one of the greatest concentrations of organic and inorganic chemical plants and refineries in the world. I've used my silver plated horn all over the area, including on the Ship Channel itself (the aforementioned gig on the USS Texas. During all of this, I've had more problems keep a lacquered horn looking good that I have with the silver plated ones.

I keep silverware protective devices (mine are little ultra-reactive chemical balls in a blue plastic case) and have never had any tarnish problems beyond those from normal handling.

One other thing. The US Army used to specify silver plate for all of its saxophones, so at least one large organization agrees with this approach. If you ever get into an argument over silver plating after claiming that you're right and you get fed a comeback "Oh yeah? Well you and who's army are going to make me believe it?", you have a ready-made reply...
 
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
Top