Sax on the Web Forum banner
1 - 20 of 58 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
1,233 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
So, as I’ve been searching around, I’ve come across a number of later model Super 20s with brass neck and bell in the ranges of 445ish to 500ish serial numbers. All marked Eastlake on bell. All, very differently priced horns. I’ve even come across a “Silversonic” in the 648ish serial range for an absolutely outrageous price. So... I guess the real question is what should someone pay for one of these horns. I’m legitimately looking more towards a series III with brass bell (preferably one I don’t have to put a tremendous amount of work/money into) but, I’m willing to entertain reasonable numbers... once I know what reasonable numbers are... Thoughts?
 

· Distinguished SOTW Member, Forum Contributor 2016
Joined
·
20,636 Posts
Nothing wrong with an Eastlake S20, or even the later 2414/2416 horns (the moniker they used after 'S20'...for some baffling reason as they were still S20's). The Tenor player in my band recently picked up a late 70's Eastlake, overslung octave key, and the thing STILL is a BEAST of a horn. Really GOOD.

So if they read Super 20 'Eastlake', Tenor without any flourishes (i.e. just brass lacq) in GOOD, serviced shape should be around $1750-2200, Alto around $1400-1700 or so.

In open bidding a couple of later project Tenors recently ended well under $1g on eFlay - one was a #484,XXX and a beater and possibly a relacq, but the other (77X,XXX) certainly looked original lacq and not in bad shape (although seller noted specifically it needed some work). Regardless, both of those were very good takes for their new owners, even computing in some substantial tech work.

After they stopped using "Eastlake" in the engraving (somewhere in the 750,XXX vicinity I think ?) , it just read "King Super 20, HN White Musical Instruments, USA"...then eventually "King 2414/2416, USA".

The latter are often unrecognized to people, they do not realize those are the last of the S20's...so you can peg one of those for quite cheap sometimes....am talking under $1g for a Tenor needing relatively minor work, and sometimes under $600 for an Alto in similar shape....
 

· Distinguished SOTW Member, Forum Contributor 2016
Joined
·
20,636 Posts

· Distinguished SOTW Member, Forum Contributor 2016
Joined
·
20,636 Posts
What sort of value would you say for a later Cleveland S20 (350-400 serial number) with silver underslung neck.
In good playing condition, straight no dents etc.
Once a silver neck appears, even on Eastlakes, the prices go up around $500 for a Tenor. This is why the brass-necked Eastlakes are such a good value, IMHO.

Once it reads "Cleveland" and has the silver neck....those become more 'desirable' as far as market goes. One in excellent shape with newish pads and recently serviced around $3400-3700 or so. One playing well on old pads and lacquer wear so-so maybe around $2700-3000. A project one with 'issues' & needing an overhaul, perhaps $1600-2100. This is 'private market', US, give or take 10%.

When you get into the Full Pearl, Silversonics and all that, things get higher...
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,835 Posts
What sort of value would you say for a later Cleveland S20 (350-400 serial number) with silver underslung neck.
In good playing condition, straight no dents etc.
I have a 354xxx and got an insurance valuation of £4000 in London last month.
 

· Distinguished SOTW Member, Forum Contributor 2016
Joined
·
20,636 Posts
I have a 354xxx and got an insurance valuation of £4000 in London last month.
That sounds right for an insurance evaluation. Just keep in mind, insured values are gonna be higher than what the market can actually fetch. So folks shouldn't use insurance appraisals as a compass of what they can sell their horn for.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,233 Posts
Discussion Starter · #18 ·
That is perhaps the issue. I am trying to decide what price point to target. I’ve seen quite few Series III for somewhere $5000 after overhaul. Some quite a bit more. I’ve also see a lot of the single sockets but at such a variance in prices. Ultimately, I’d like something with the sound of a Super 20. I would prefer and underslung neck. Plausibly silver (but how it plays is most important). The silver bell is a pseudo afterthought. I am tending towards a brass bell just because I think that makes less difference by country mile than the neck. I really would prefer to find something that I don’t have to get a full overhaul at this time but... if the price is right... unfortunately to go to people good close by (for the overhaul), it is quite expensive.
 

· Distinguished SOTW Member, Forum Contributor 2016
Joined
·
20,636 Posts
That is perhaps the issue. I am trying to decide what price point to target. I've seen quite few Series III for somewhere $5000 after overhaul. Some quite a bit more. I've also see a lot of the single sockets but at such a variance in prices. Ultimately, I'd like something with the sound of a Super 20. I would prefer and underslung neck. Plausibly silver (but how it plays is most important). The silver bell is a pseudo afterthought. I am tending towards a brass bell just because I think that makes less difference by country mile than the neck. I really would prefer to find something that I don't have to get a full overhaul at this time but... if the price is right... unfortunately to go to people good close by, it is quite expensive.
If you find something and are in US, I can do the overhaul for you....I tend to come out far cheaper than techs who tend to be on the pricier side, even with shipping back-forth taken into account.

$5000 for a series III which is NOT a full pearl....that just isn't a realistic price point (although for sure a very reputed, high-end shop can pricetag one at that AND get a buyer). I recently sold a minty Full Pearl series III for $4200, talking 85% orig lacq...and it was listed for a few weeks, didn't get 'snatched up' by any means.

I agree, the silver bell is purely aesthetic. I would say that the silver neck, sort of the same. HOWEVER, I can also say THIS:

Having had a late Cleve, silver neck AND an early Eastlake brass neck here in my shop once, simultaneously:

They were 90% the SAME instrument. The body specs were IDENTICAL (this means body tube, bow, bellpiece dimensions, keyguards, posts, and weight were the SAME). Yes, this contradicts saxpics, but that site is no longer run by Pete and hasn't been updated in almost a decade...so there's info there which is dead wrong.

The differences between my 2 were:

1) pinky table touches slightly different shape

2) the brass necks on the Eastlakes, besides having a conventional Tenon as opposed to double-socket neck.... had a different tube design....they were a different taper and a bit longer, as I recall. THIS resulted in the brass-neck Eastlakes blowing a bit brighter than the late Cleves.
When I played the silver Cleveland neck on the Eastlake body, it sounded identical to the Cleve horn with silver Cleve neck. When I played the brass Eastlake neck on the Cleve body, it brightened the tone a bit and sounded like the Eastlake. Intonation was still good regardless of neck swap.

With THAT said...BOTH horns with their factory necks..."sounded" like S20's. The signature tonality, harmonics, etc. was all still there. The Cleves just blew a tad darker. Which is NOT :| to say the Eastlake brew 'bright'...if you get my drift.

So, having refurbished around a dozen S20's of various eras...I would say to YOU: if you want the 'sound of an S20'...worry not, you can buy anything from a Series I all the way to a King 2416...and get "THAT sound". It will be there whether a '47 or a '80.

The 1, having the Zeph-type table, is also a horn which doesn't fetch as much as the others, because of that table (a fine vintage-style table, BTW).

So the question would next become: are you really wedded to an underslung neck ? If so, are you wedded to a Silver underslung ?
If you are set on silver, then be aware that that is gonna hit your wallet.

If there were the 'next question' beyond this, I suppose it'd be the feel of the tables. IMHO, while the touches changed shape a bit (the Eastlake touches are flat, most Cleve touches are shaped and rounded a bit more), I do not think one was more ergonomically preferable to the other (disregarding the Zeph type table of the I's, of course). But some folks might think so.

Those would then inform the range of horns you'd be looking at...
 

· Registered
Joined
·
747 Posts
an eastlake tenor sold locally for 1200 last year - don't remember if it was early or late in the series. my experience with the s20's with silver, double socket neck in good playing condition is they are around 3k . most of the big shops are going to ask a lot more for a horn than what the average seller on here is going to get / ask.
 
1 - 20 of 58 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top