There are things about Joshua Redman's playing that bother me and aren't my favorite things to hear him do. But, he is who he is and not trying to be anybody he isn't. Hasn't he developed a personal conception? What more do we want? Don't you think most players could recognize him in two bars?
I think more so when he was younger, I could hear him thinking. The quartet he has now has pushed him to a place where I can't hear him thinking. You know what I'm talking about. You hear players that not quite ready for prime time, they have brain fade or get momentarily lost or raggedy phrases. They are trying to remember the Badd licks they were practicing in their bedroom... not being in the moment and playing with the group. After three tunes you heard it all... or two tunes.
There are things that sonny Rollins plays that don't really resonate well with me. It doesn't stop me from wanting to see him or loving the guy.
I got a pile of Coltrane records, CDs, box sets. I never listen to Trane, except on Christmas day or my birthday... or he gets played on KMHD.org. Trane disturbs me. I love Trane so much, but a lot of him just tears me apart.
In fact, I haven't bought recordings in 10 years. All my records, CDs and stereo gear has been in storage for ever and the radio in my truck barely works. I watch some YouTube, but I would rather spend the time playing.
Somebody gave me Freedom in the Groove, I listened to that a lot, but unless I heard it on the radio, I have no idea what any of his records are like. I only know what he sounds like live.
JL, remember the billboard going north bound on 101 by Almany Blvd.??? IS IT LIVE OR IS IT MEMOREX? The guy slunched down in the chair with his hair and tie blowing back from the cranked stereo? I said, Is is Live or is it Memorex? to somebody the other day. They had no idea what I was talking about. You know Steve at Coastside Recorders in Pescadero by any chance? He told me, recordings are the same every time you listen to them. That's it all you get.
I haven't seen Joshua play the same thing twice.
How about this; There are a lot of sax players that for what ever reason registered on my BS Meter. When I finally got to see them play live, I was sold. The records were BS. I was prepared to not like any kind of jive at all, but when musicians can play a burning set, burning solos and get the audience to dig it, that is the test. Guys like Richard Elliot, Boney James, Nelson Rangel, Jeff Kashawa, Andy Snitzer, Eric Marionthal... good players, good performers. Do I listen to or buy their records? NO. I would go see them play though.
I'm going to go see Azar Lawrence next week, I hope. Looking forward to Sonny Rollins play with the symphony soon. I was a music fan before I was ever a player, and I'm always going to be a fan.