Glad to hear you found the horn that suited you. But picking a sax is such a personal experience, I have heard this story where the selmer, yani, or yamaha would have won out.
Interesting Soprano purchase
Hi all,
Had an interesting experience buying a soprano yesterday, thought somebody might like to have the information.
I have been playing saxophone for about a month, after playing the trumpet for 40 years. I've been playing tenor, but I knew I would be getting a soprano in short order...I've always wanted to play one.
Yesterday I went down to Rayburn's in Boston and tried three sopranos:
-a used Yani 902
-a Selmer series II
-a Yamaha (don't know the model)
Of these three, the Yani was nice, hated the Selmer, and the Yamaha was surprisingly (to me) nice. I also took a friend of mine who's an experienced saxophonist and had him play each horn, to get his opinion, and so I could hear the horns played by someone else.
I went back out and asked about the prices of the Yani and the Yamaha:
-yani 2200 (not bad, horn was immaculate)
-Yamaha 1600 (again not bad)
I happened to look in the case and spotted a saxello (which is something I've always dug) and asked to try that. BINGO! I knew after three notes that this was the horn I wanted. Great sound, played in tune, and seemed to blow freer than the others.
It's a P. Mauriat with a flat silverish finish with black mother of pearl (I think) keys. Price was 1900 and change.
Anyway, I'm sure that there are souls out there who are as confused as I was about which horns to try/buy....I hope this information helps.
bigtiny
Had an interesting experience buying a soprano yesterday, thought somebody might like to have the information.
I have been playing saxophone for about a month, after playing the trumpet for 40 years. I've been playing tenor, but I knew I would be getting a soprano in short order...I've always wanted to play one.
Yesterday I went down to Rayburn's in Boston and tried three sopranos:
-a used Yani 902
-a Selmer series II
-a Yamaha (don't know the model)
Of these three, the Yani was nice, hated the Selmer, and the Yamaha was surprisingly (to me) nice. I also took a friend of mine who's an experienced saxophonist and had him play each horn, to get his opinion, and so I could hear the horns played by someone else.
I went back out and asked about the prices of the Yani and the Yamaha:
-yani 2200 (not bad, horn was immaculate)
-Yamaha 1600 (again not bad)
I happened to look in the case and spotted a saxello (which is something I've always dug) and asked to try that. BINGO! I knew after three notes that this was the horn I wanted. Great sound, played in tune, and seemed to blow freer than the others.
It's a P. Mauriat with a flat silverish finish with black mother of pearl (I think) keys. Price was 1900 and change.
Anyway, I'm sure that there are souls out there who are as confused as I was about which horns to try/buy....I hope this information helps.
bigtiny
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
bigtiny,
Thank you for your report.
It helped to remind me that P.M. may be a viable
option when the day comes, even though I have not
even seen one yet.
Enjoy your new horn, I envy you.
rabbit
Thank you for your report.
It helped to remind me that P.M. may be a viable
option when the day comes, even though I have not
even seen one yet.
Enjoy your new horn, I envy you.
rabbit
Joel,joelsp said:Glad to hear you found the horn that suited you. But picking a sax is such a personal experience, I have heard this story where the selmer, yani, or yamaha would have won out.
I absolutely agree, I wanted to let people know about the Mauriat and to also let them know that it IS a very subjective thing. I mean, I'm sure there some people read my note and thought "Jeez, what a dufus, he could have had a Yani for a couple of hundred bucks more..." But, you know, I like the Mauriat.....and that's what counts.
bigtiny
Too bad you didn't throw a good old vintage soprano into your mix of choices...
Congrats on the buy. But you may want to revisit the other horns after a year or two of playing, after you know your way around not just the saxophone but the soprano. It's a quirky beast.
Are you and the bigtiny at JazzCorner one and the same?
Are you and the bigtiny at JazzCorner one and the same?
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
- This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Sax on the Web Forum
A forum community dedicated to saxophone players and enthusiasts originally founded by Harri Rautiainen. Come join the discussion about collections, care, displays, models, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!
Full Forum Listing
Recommended Communities
