Sax on the Web Forum banner

help me id these 2 vintage alto mpc's, please

1367 Views 5 Replies 5 Participants Last post by  milandro
Not even in the market but I went to a garage sale over the past weekend, and there was a beat up "from the thirties, I think"(the seller said) trumpet that had a very cheap price and I could tell it was a silver plated horn, so I bought it. But why I bought it was that there were two obvious sax mpc's in the case. One is a Vandoren and one is a Johnston-Selmer. This morning with a bit of cold water, dish soap and my fingertips only I cleaned off what crud I could, and they appear to be in decent shape; I put a new #3 vandoren reed to each, they seal and play pretty nice, the vandoren deep and rich, the selmer projects like crazy. Now, I think I've Id'd the Selmer as being an A.Lelandais from 1934, but where there should a a star engraving it's scratched so I could be mistaken. The question is, what do I have here, and are they worth holding on to? To clarify I have no intention of selling them, I mean hold on to more in the sense that are they regarded as good players or not, etc. Thanks for any insights!
See less See more
1 - 2 of 6 Posts
I guess the answer lies within. Would you play them? . Once you sell a mouthpiece or horn for that matter it's gone and whatever enrichment you may have gained dissipates quickly, while regrets last forever.
Yeah, the vandoren maybe. I currently play a c table Selmer for my alto, this has a nice dark sound. I guess I'd have to put more time into each and not just 2 minutes of scales once they were cleaned for a quick first impression test. otherwise, into the drawer it goes.
1 - 2 of 6 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.