Based on what you've narrowed it down to, I would think the Dukoff or the Guardala would be your best choices.
How did you narrow it down?? by playing all these pieces?
I use a Dukoff for contemporary jazz and funk on both alto and tenor. I also have a pair of Saxscape Downtowns that also work great for this stuff, but I struggle doubling alto and tenor using the Saxscape pieces, so I pretty much use the Dukoffs exclusively now.
I prefer Dukoff M's over D's.. I've had both, and I now play M's only. I think they play a little fatter than the D's, especially in the upper register, and there is just a little more body and core to the tone.