[saxdude48]

Hey guys
I'm trying to decide which one of these two to order for myself. Either the "Vol 31: Jazz Bossa Novas" or "Vol 98: Antonio Carlos Jobim Bossa Novas". But I can't decide which one. I consider myself an intermediate level improviser, so I don't want something which will be too easy, or way to hard.
Also, I noticed they both feature a lot of the same songs. Apart from the addition of the guitar in vol 98, what else is different about these 2 books?
Thanks

 

[kingperkoff]

Volume 98 is way better, IMOP. The rhythm section grooves more and the tempos are slower.

 

[stjontl]

Yes, I think vol 98 is better... The guitarist is comping more in a latin way, adding a real nice brazilian flavor to the tracks.

 

[kavala]

I have 98 but not the other so I can't compare.

However, Vol 98 will give you a good starter in Jobim.

 

[Off-kilter]

The Answer Is 98!

I'll put in a word for volume 98 as well. It's my personal preference also. I really like how the tunes are performed with this one , more than I can say for a lot of others in the series. The one exception is 'Once I Loved' which is done at a breakneck pace:shock: which I consider inappropriate for a sad ballad but maybe it's because I'm such a fan of Shirley Horn's version .This book will keep you plenty busy before you feel the need to move on to 'Summer Samba' and the like.My 2 cents (CDN).

 

[jazzsax07]

I have an unopened v.31 that I will sell for $10 plus postage.
It was given to me as a gift and I already have one. I also have v.98.
I like both and alternate between the two.
pm me if interested.

 

[saxobari]

Both books are great! Though the 98 is a favorite of mind! Buy bofb ,,,they are fantastic volumes!
Saxobari

 

[Agent27]

I like Vol. 98. The sound quality is better and they use guitar which is a nice change of pace from the piano bossas.