PDA

View Full Version : S1 vs Yamaha


duner9
09-04-2004, 05:39 AM
So with all this money burning a hole in my pocket from the recent sale of my tenor Mark VI, and the acceptance that I just like alto better, I went off to the nearest Sam Ash. I've read voraciously about every nuance of every Yamaha ever produced. I even watched their little factory movie, and so I was ready. I was armed with my VanDoren MPC and reed. They only had a 62II in alto. I've read great things about this horn. I greased up my cork and aligned my reed. I stood in the corner, my eyes closed, and blew. No big whoop. I own a beautiful S1. There was nothing special in the keys or in the sound of that 62II that was worth the $1800 price tag. The sound is in the mouth anyway. Instead of practicing, I had spent my time reading about saxophones. It always comes to this. You don't need the best camera to take great photos...you need an eye. You don't need the so-called best horn. You need your mouth, but us humans love to dvelve into minutiae. It was then that it hit me. It's the sound, stupid. The horn is nothing more than a conduit for that sound, created in the mouth. I'm keeping my S1 and am going back to blowing it or writing about blowing it.

singlereed
09-04-2004, 07:28 AM
The S1 is considered to be one of the best saxes ever made. Nothing wrong with a Yamaha 62, but I would say the S1 is more characterful and is a beautifully made horn, so unless you have a problem with it, tick the box named 'professional horn, no need to consider replacement' and get on with playing it.

mostly alto guy
09-04-2004, 05:39 PM
Dead on, singlereed. Though each player has preferences, I don't see how anyone could go wrong with an S1. Mine gets more playing time than any of my other altos, and I have some very nice ones. There's just something about feel and playability of a good S1, and that sound...

Maybe I should be like duner9; divest myself of some of my horns, use the money to hire a good teacher, and get on with playing instead of collecting.

Gange
09-05-2004, 07:24 PM
Talking about cameras;
Comparing an S1 to a(ny) Yamaha is like comparing a Hasselblad to a Konica.

Check out www.hasselblad.se and www.konica.com to get "the picture". :-)