Are these fair trades?

[Saxaholic]

All horns mentioned here are in perfect physical condition and ready to play. Question is.....what do you guys think of these trades?

1934 Conn 6M Alto 98% original silver plate.

Traded for:

232XXX Buescher Straight Soprano 98% original Gold Plate.

OR

Cannonball Big Bell series Black nickel Tenor

OR

Yanigisawa S991 Straight Soprano 99% original lacquer.

Which one would you guys go for? ( I'm partial to either tenor or soprano...maybe leaning a little towards soprano)

[mostly alto guy]

You can always find another Yani or Cannonball, even if you have to buy new. Assuming it's straight (I mean not banged up or bent) and plays well (doesn't need repairs or pads right way), go for the Buescher.

[Dr Loud]

I'd go for the Yanigasawa soprano! :roll: